Bit 063 cover card, They Treat Our IP as Freeware: On how generative AI treats publicly accessible cultural work as free raw material while the resulting models, products and profits remain strictly proprietary.

There is something almost elegant about the intellectual-property politics of generative AI. Our books, illustrations, photographs, code, music, forum posts and other cultural work are treated as if being publicly accessible made them available for industrial use. Suddenly the language is all about openness, learning, innovation and the impossibility of asking permission at scale.

Then the material passes through the machine and comes out the other side as a proprietary model, a paid subscription, an API, an enterprise license and ultimately somebody else’s asset. The openness apparently only travels in one direction. Our intellectual property is treated like freeware; theirs remains property.

This is why the debate is bigger than copyright compliance. It is about enclosure. Culture produced collectively and individually over decades becomes raw material for privately owned infrastructure, and the companies doing the enclosing get to describe the extraction itself as progress. Funny how quickly the commitment to open knowledge ends once there is something valuable to own.

← Back to Bits

The book

A(I)mbivalence is a book now.

In English and in German, each as an ebook, a paperback, and a hardcover.