Bit 064 cover card, The Ring Does Not Need You to Be Evil: On why the One Ring, like AI, does not need people who want to do harm, only good reasons to reach for more power.

The One Ring does not tempt people by asking them to become evil. It offers them power to do something they already believe is good. Protect your people. Win the war. Become more capable. Finally have enough power to fix what everybody else keeps failing to fix. That is what makes the temptation interesting.

AI spreads in much the same way. Most people are not using it because they want to deskill themselves, undermine workers or hand more power to a few technology companies. They want to get through an impossible workload, write better, understand something faster, help somebody, make something they could not make before. The usefulness is real. So are the reasons for reaching for it.

That is why “people should simply make better choices” is such a weak political answer. Technologies become powerful precisely when using them makes sense for individuals while the collective consequences remain somewhere outside the decision. The Ring does not need bad people. It only needs good reasons.

← Back to Bits

The book

A(I)mbivalence is a book now.

In English and in German, each as an ebook, a paperback, and a hardcover.